My Company's Sold Listings - Page 19 - Tibitha "Tibi" Matheney

My Company's Sold Listings

$300,000 ^(USD)

Fairview Heights Area Single Family Home

583 Wyndclift Circle Austintown, OH 44515

Meticulous two story with great features! Have you been searching for a fenced in yard? Do you need space to entertain and do crop dream of a pool to enjoy in the warm months? So many great options for you here! Smartly added additional third parking row removes the need for musical cars in the morning! Inviting covered front entry leads to a welcoming foyer entry. To the right is a large living room, plus spacious formal dining. The remodeled kitchen has fantastic cabinets with lots of bells and whistles, plus gorgeous neutral granite countertops, appliances are included. The dinette includes a moveable island seating station. The large family room features a brick fireplace, room for comfortable furniture and the slider doors overlooking the deck, pool & backyard! Lawn furniture can stay for you to enjoy this spring! Heading upstairs, the half bath is conveniently located at the front of the home. At the top of the stairs is a full guest bath with tub shower combo. The spacious primary suite offers a full private bath, dressing table & huge closets! Two additional guest bedrooms are available, both with great closet space. The full basement offers a nice sized carpeted rec room plus a large laundry/utility room. High efficiency furnace, central air. Washer dryer and second fridge to stay for the new owner. The fenced yard offers so much space to enjoy. There is a sturdy shed to store all of your tools and lawn care equipment, plus the owner is leaving all of the pool equipment for the above ground pool. Call today to set your showing appointment!

Listing Courtesy of

YES MLS / Listed By: Tibitha Matheney, Century 21 Lakeside Realty

$300,000 ^(USD)

Elm Knoll Heights 1 Area Single Family Home

6154 Navajo Place Youngstown, OH 44514

FANTASTIC POLAND RANCH!! This WONDERFUL HOME has been BEAUTIFULLY REMODELED and is ready to JUST MOVE IN!! Featuring Living Room with coved ceiling, hardwood floors & FIREPLACE; Dining Room with new trim & hardwood floors, Kitchen with new counter tops, sink & flooring; Three Bedrooms with large closets & hardwood floors; Fully UPDATED BATHROOM; Second FULL BATH with Jack & Jill double entry doors; Full Basement with large REC ROOM; Over sized Laundry Room with HALF BATHROOM & storage area; ATTACHED TWO CAR GARAGE with newer opener; Front Porch and COVERED BACK PATIO for relaxing outdoors. Additional updated items include: NEW ROOF shingles, FRESHLY PAINTED throughout, light fixtures, some custom trim, light switches, outlets, door knobs/hinges and garbage disposal. DON'T MISS OUT!! Call to scheduled your showing TODAY!!!

Listing Courtesy of

YES MLS / Listed By: Kathy Ludt, Century 21 Lakeside Realty

$300,000 ^(USD)

Latest Enumeration/Lots/Sa Area Single Family Home

126 Garwood Drive Canfield, OH 44406

Bright and cheery! Step into this gorgeously updated ranch home in the highly sought after neighborhood, just minutes from the esteemed Canfield School District. This home displays pride of ownership. 4 bedrooms/3 bathrooms and plenty of living space. The sunroom will quickly become your favorite room! This home has had so many updates within the last 4 years. Metal roof, black triple-pane windows, gutters, downspouts, soffit, facia, garage door and opener, flooring, bathroom tub and surround, new lighting with a ton of can lights throughout, gfci outlets and new Whirlpool kitchen appliances. The basement was repaired in 2022, with straitening block, replace drain tile, rebar and concrete in walls and waterproofed, with a lifetime transferable warranty. This home is completely move-in ready and the major items are done. Don’t wait on this one!

Listing Courtesy of

YES MLS / Listed By: Forever Homes Realty

$300,000 ^(USD)

Logan Estates Area Single Family Home

4775 Logan Arms Drive Liberty, OH 44505

Welcome to 4775 Logan Arms, where modern elegance meets timeless comfort in the heart of Liberty, Ohio. This captivating four-bedroom, two-bathroom home, with its generous 2,516 square feet, is more than just a place to live—it's a canvas for your dreams. Step inside to discover a newly updated haven, where fresh paint whispers a promise of new beginnings. The lower level, transformed in April 2026, boasts new flooring, trim, and doors, creating a seamless blend of style and function. Imagine cozy evenings in a space that's been lovingly renewed, each detail crafted for comfort and ease. Feel the reassurance of modern living with a new furnace and A/C installed in 2024, ensuring year-round comfort. The updated electrical panel and rewired attic bring peace of mind, allowing you to focus on what truly matters—making memories. Sunlight dances through the windows, illuminating spacious rooms that invite you to relax and stay awhile. Picture mornings in your serene kitchen, afternoons filled with laughter in the living room, and evenings under the stars in your private outdoor sanctuary. Every inch of this home invites you to imagine a life well-lived. The quiet surroundings offer a peaceful retreat, yet you're never far from the vibrant community that makes Liberty so special. This is more than a house—it's your future. Roof 2017, Hot Water Tank 2022, Partial New windows 2022. Don't miss the opportunity to make it yours. Contact me today to schedule your private showing and take the first step toward living the life you've always imagined. Seller is motivated and all offers will be considered. Don't miss out on this opportunity.

Listing Courtesy of

YES MLS / Listed By: Melissa DeFabbo, Century 21 Lakeside Realty

$300,000 ^(USD)

Columbiana Area Single Family Home

929 E Park Avenue Columbiana, OH 44408

Beautiful Brick Home on an Acre with Bonus Two Bedroom Apartment! Welcome to this charming brick Cape Cod nestled on an acre in desirable Columbiana! Step inside to a spacious living and dining area highlighted by a cozy fireplace, and a bright kitchen with a breakfast bar. The main floor includes a convenient bedroom and full bath with shower—perfect for guests or single-level living. Upstairs, you’ll find a large 23x13 primary bedroom with newer laminate flooring and generous closet space, a third bedroom, and another full bath with bathtub. The basement offers great bonus space, including a potential rec room, fruit cellar, laundry area, and more. Outside, enjoy the freshly stained two-tier deck, relaxing patio, and a beautifully maintained garden that’s ready for summer evenings or morning coffee. A standout feature is the two bedroom apartment located in the bonus outbuilding—offering a private living room, kitchen with appliances, two bedrooms, 1.5 bathrooms, and its own heated garage with workbench. Whether you need space for extended family, a hobby room, or a private retreat, this versatile setup delivers. Commercial C-4 Zoning allows for many possible uses with this property. Schedule your private showing today! (Back on Market due to Buyer's financing falling through. No fault of Sellers.)

Listing Courtesy of

YES MLS / Listed By: Kathy Ludt, Century 21 Lakeside Realty

$300,000 ^(USD)

Brentwood 02 Area Single Family Home

8021 Middlesex Road Mentor, OH 44060

Welcome home to a beautifully maintained, move-in-ready 4-bedroom, 2-bath gem in the heart of Mentor—offering the rare combination of space, character, and major recent upgrades that today’s buyers crave.

Sitting on nearly a half-acre, this home delivers exceptional versatility, comfort, and convenience. The thoughtfully designed layout features an upper-level primary suite and three generously sized bedrooms that provide flexibility for a growing household.

The main level welcomes you with a warm and inviting living room centered around a stone wood-burning fireplace, perfect for cozy evenings. A fourth bedroom—currently used as a family room—adds even more gathering space. The updated 2024 kitchen shines with butcher block countertops, abundant cabinetry, and stainless steel and black appliances, all included.

A standout feature is the large mudroom and laundry area with direct access from the attached garage—washer and dryer included. Above the garage, a spacious loft with wide-plank wood flooring (installed 2022) offers endless possibilities: home office, playroom, or additional storage.

Step outside to a private oasis: screened porch, expansive deck, patio, and firepit overlook a serene, tree-lined yard that feels like the countryside while keeping you close to city convenience. The yard has been professionally landscaped, trees trimmed 2026.

This home has been meticulously cared for, with major high-ticket updates already completed:
Located in one of Mentor’s most beloved neighborhoods, you’ll enjoy quick access to schools, shopping, parks, recreation, dining, and Headlands Beach. Commuters will appreciate being just minutes from major highways and roughly 25 minutes from Downtown Cleveland.

This is not a cookie-cutter home—it’s a property filled with character, functionality, and room to grow. With its unbeatable location, extensive updates, and exceptional indoor-outdoor living spaces, this Mentor home is truly a rare find.

Listing Courtesy of

YES MLS / Listed By: Leslie Hetherington, Century 21 Lakeside Realty

$300,000 ^(USD)

Champion Manor Area Single Family Home

348 Aspen Drive NW Warren, OH 44483

Hurry in for the summer, stay for a lifetime of fun and memories! You’ll have plenty of room to make them too, as this delightful Champion estate finds you with three floors of finished living space to include its partially finished basement. Instantly attracting with its handsome brick accents, manicured landscaping and stone-laid sidewalk, the residence packs a curb appeal punch that continues into the fenced-in backyard. Here, welcome the summer days ahead while relaxing in the crystal-clear pool, lounging on the expansive deck work or by shooting some hoops on the half court. A cozy fire pit looks on, awaiting the nightlife. Step inside to find a rising, wood trimmed staircase as a carpeted living room beckons you near. The sprawling central kitchen includes a large center island, hidden pantry and a neatly tiled backsplash. Eat-in dining looks on while taking advantage of the patio entrance provided sunshine. Curl up with your favorite book as you immerse yourself in the fireplace laden family room, complete with artful, overhead beams that pair well with the hardwood style flooring below. A half bath rounds out the floor near garage and basement access where laundry services are also found. Upstairs, four impressively sized bedrooms branch from the main hall to include the oversized master suite and its included full private bath. A second, colorfully appointed full bath joins the engaging bedrooms at mid hall. Call today to be first through the door!

Listing Courtesy of

YES MLS / Listed By: Brokers Realty Group

$300,000 ^(USD)

Newton Township Sec 16 Area Manufactured Home

3420 Newton Tomlinson Road SW Warren, OH 44481

Country charm meets exceptional business potential on this stunning 4.5-acre property featuring a beautifully maintained, move-in-ready home and a remarkable 3,200 sq ft heated and cooled outbuilding. This is a converted manufactured home, as the axles have been removed. It has a block foundation and features a very tall crawl space of over 3 feet high. The home boasts sturdy 6-inch, well-insulated walls, an open and inviting floor plan with a cozy fireplace, dining area, screened-in porch, and a well-appointed kitchen featuring a breakfast bar. The generous primary suite offers two luxurious bathing areas—one with a double vanity and a walk-in tub, the other with a walk-in shower, toilet, a linen closet, and an additional walk-in storage closet. Two additional bedrooms and another full bathroom, also featuring a double vanity, complete the home. Enjoy peace of mind with a brand-new central air and heating system, as well as newer, well-maintained appliances. The home and outbuilding have a backup generator. Owners are acquiring a guaranteed septic quote and will escrow for the septic upgrade, which is approximately a $20,000 savings to the buyer.

Entrepreneurs will be captivated by the versatile outbuilding featuring multiple man doors, garage doors, and four oversized rooms—including a carpeted space perfect for an office or studio. Formerly a tack supply business, this unique space is ideal for a workshop, creative venture, or home-based business. Don’t rent space for your business—own it here! Completed soil test and home inspection with repairs done. Nestled on a quiet road with serene golf course views and proximity to three horse racing venues, this property offers a rare blend of peaceful country living and endless opportunity.

Listing Courtesy of

YES MLS / Listed By: Kimberly Montecalvo, Century 21 Lakeside Realty

$300,000 ^(USD)

New Waterford Area Single Family Home

3355 Waterford Road New Waterford, OH 44445

Looking for a little peace, a lot of space, and your own private slice of nature? This property offers the best of both worlds with indoor comfort all nestled on 2.82 wooded acres with a peaceful creek, mature trees, and plenty of room to breathe. From the moment you step inside, you’ll feel the warmth and character throughout. The main living area features a spacious layout with a large stone fireplace that brings both charm and comfort, perfect for cozy evenings, weekend gatherings, or simply enjoying the quiet. The living room flows into a functional eat-in kitchen with ample cabinet space and room to customize to your taste. The first floor also offers two comfortable bedrooms and a full bathroom, making single-level living an option. Upstairs, the lofted primary suite serves as a private getaway with its own full bath, walk-in closet, and an additional attic area tucked inside for convenient storage or a quiet hideaway. Just outside the primary bedroom is a large open loft space, perfect for a home office, reading area, playroom, or hobby zone. Downstairs, the walkout basement offers one finished room that could be used as a guest space, office, or media room. The rest of the lower level is framed and partially finished, giving you the opportunity to add even more living space exactly how you want it. The possibilities here are wide open. Outside, you'll find a concrete patio that overlooks the wooded yard and the gently flowing creek beyond. Whether you're enjoying your morning coffee, winding down in the evening, or watching wildlife pass through, this space offers an unmatched sense of peace and privacy. The two-car attached garage adds everyday convenience, and the long driveway offers plenty of extra parking. Oil heat keeps the home warm during Ohio winters, and all appliances will remain with the property, making your move even easier. The home offers flexibility, comfort, and a location that feels tucked away without being far from local amenities.

Listing Courtesy of

YES MLS / Listed By: Jessica Hinerman, Century 21 Lakeside Realty

$299,900 ^(USD)

North Park Estates Area Single Family Home

1019 Park Circle Girard, OH 44420

Welcome home to this beautifully updated ranch nestled on a spacious corner lot in a desirable neighborhood. Offering spacious single-level living, this 3-bedroom, 2-bath home has been thoughtfully renovated from top to bottom, blending timeless character with modern updates. Step inside to discover all-new interior doors, fresh paint throughout, stylish new lighting, and brand-new flooring that flows seamlessly from room to room. The completely updated kitchen features new cabinetry, countertops, and appliances, creating a bright and functional space perfect for everyday living and entertaining. Both bathrooms have been fully renovated with tasteful, modern finishes. This home offers two unique fireplaces, adding warmth and charm to multiple living areas. Major mechanical updates provide peace of mind, including updated plumbing, a brand-new electrical service (April 2026), newer furnace, and brand-new central air installed in 2026. The exterior is equally impressive with a new front door for added curb appeal and two attached two-car garages, providing a total of four parking spaces and ample storage. Enjoy the beautifully wooded lot with fresh landscaping, offering both privacy and a serene outdoor setting. A standout feature is the clubhouse-style shed complete with windows, dual entrances, and a built-in workbench—perfect for hobbies, storage, or a creative retreat. Completely move-in ready with extensive updates throughout, this home is a rare find that combines quality, style, and functionality. Schedule your showing today—this one won’t last long!

Listing Courtesy of

YES MLS / Listed By: Amanda Silvestri, Century 21 Lakeside Realty

Home

Properties

About Me

Blog

Neighborhood News

Terms Of Use | Privacy Policy | Accessibility Statement | Fair Housing Notice

© 2026 MoxiWorks

© CENTURY 21 2023 - 2024. All rights reserved. CENTURY 21®, C21® and the CENTURY 21 Logo are registered service marks owned by Century 21 Real Estate LLC. Franchisee Legal Entity Name (not the dba) fully supports the principles of the Fair Housing Act and the Equal Opportunity Act. Each franchise is independently owned and operated. Any services or products provided by independently owned and operated franchisees are not provided by, affiliated with, or related to Century 21 Real Estate LLC nor any of its affiliated companies.