My Company's Sold Listings - Page 24 - Tibitha "Tibi" Matheney

My Company's Sold Listings

$279,900 ^(USD)

Poland Village Area Single Family Home

226 Edna Street Youngstown, OH 44514

**New roof installation will be completed before closing**
This 3 bedroom ranch-style home, located in the Poland Village, is just the home you have been looking for! Enjoy the ease of single-floor living with this functional and inviting floor plan featuring a kitchen with granite countertops, tile backsplash, under cabinet lighting, a full suite of stainless steel appliances (a stove, refrigerator, and dishwasher), Hunter Douglas blinds, and ample cabinetry. The adjacent dining area has two built-in corner China cabinets, adding a touch of charm. The dining and living room have hard wood flooring and large windows for natural light. The living room has a cozy gas fireplace as well as French doors that lead to an outdoor area with a fire pit to enjoy! The primary bedroom has custom California Closets, maximizing storage and organization. All three bedrooms have hard wood flooring and Hunter Douglas blinds. You will find generous closet space and additional storage solutions throughout the home.
This home also has a partially finished basement. The finished area is ideal for a recreational room or guest space equipped with a decorative fireplace and plenty of light from the egress windows. Washer and dryer are also included. The basement has also just been partially waterproofed. As a special bonus, Unwind in your very own built-in Sauna, a feature that brings spa-level comfort to your home!
Seller is providing a one year home warranty. An electric fence is also included.
Dont miss out on this incredible opportunity!

Listing Courtesy of

YES MLS / Listed By: Kelly Haren, Century 21 Lakeside Realty

$279,607 ^(USD)

Boardman Area Single Family Home

804 Crestview Drive Boardman, OH 44512

WOW, have you always dreamed of living seconds from Mill Creek Park? Are you a lover of wildlife and other treasures the Park brings? How about Golf? Would you love to live a minute from Mil Creek Golf Course? THIS IS THE LOCATION! Not many homes pop up for sale here, especially a ranch Sitting on two lots equalling 1.21 acres. Walk in to a spacious foyer with double coat closet Huge living room dining room combination. Woodburning fireplace, bookcase and excellent natural light flood thru the windows. A door leading to the enclosed sunroom. The kitchen comes with appliances, corian countertops, newer updated cabinets and a great eat in dinette overlooking the back and side porches. Enclosed 19 x 11 porch is awesome to relax in the evening and check out the deer who come for a visit. Off the porch is a covered and uncovered patio, it’s the best of all worlds to enjoy this property! Sun or shade, we got you Covered! Three spacious bedrooms, a full and half bath both on the first floor, great closet space plus linen storage. The previously partially waterproofed basement offers a huge family room with wood burning fireplace, kitchenette and gas stove stays. Enormous additional unfinished spaces, laundry area (washer and dryer will stay) Central Air, updated high efficiency furnace 2/19/2026, glass block windows, Sump Pump 03/26. Looking for space for additional cars? Have an outdoor hobby and need the space? Check this out! This home has an attached 2 car garage and a detached two car garage as well. If Mill Creek Park is calling your name, if this is one of the homes you have driven by for years and always wanted to buy it or if it is one that is just catching your eye today, pick up your phone and call me! You will be so happy you did!

Listing Courtesy of

YES MLS / Listed By: Tibitha Matheney, Century 21 Lakeside Realty

$279,500 ^(USD)

Warren Area Multi-Family Home

1536-1548 Montclair Street NE Warren, OH 44483

ATTENTION INVESTORS, the perfect opportunity awaits you. This fully occupied, multi-family property offers a total of 4,272 square feet of living space across multiple units. There is one parcel ID but 2 buildings with 2 units in each. Built in 1970, the residence sits on a 0.58-acre lot and includes a 7-car garage, providing ample parking for tenants. The property features 8 bedrooms and 4.5 bathrooms, making it suitable for various rental configurations. Each unit is equipped with air conditioning and most appliances which make renting a breeze. This property presents a solid investment opportunity with its spacious units and ample parking.

Listing Courtesy of

YES MLS / Listed By: Stella Kotsatos-Angelo, Century 21 Lakeside Realty

$279,000 ^(USD)

Lordstown Village Area Single Family Home

3691 Lyntz Townline Road SW Lordstown, OH 44481

Beautifully renovated from top to bottom, this 4-bedroom, 2.5-bathroom home is ready to welcome its new owners. Step inside to find refinished hardwood floors throughout. The kitchen is a true highlight, featuring high-end updates that make cooking and gathering a joy. The spacious master bedroom offers a walk-in closet and a stunning private bathroom, while the additional bedrooms provide plenty of room for family, guests, or a home office. Convenient first-floor laundry and a half bath add extra ease to everyday living. Outside, enjoy summer evenings or weekend get-togethers on the large back deck overlooking the beautiful backyard, a perfect space to relax or entertain. Don’t miss your chance to call this move-in ready home yours, schedule a showing today!

Listing Courtesy of

YES MLS / Listed By: Jessica Calleja, Century 21 Lakeside Realty

$279,000 ^(USD)

Mineral Ridge Area Single Family Home

1208 Cedarwood Drive Mineral Ridge, OH 44440

Vacation at home, this summer and all of your summers to come, while watching the sunset from the large deck, overlooking your fabulous inground swimming pool! Even in Ohio's cool weather months, this 3 bedroom, 1 1/2 bath home welcomes with its focal point brick fireplace, in the large family room that is open to the fashionable eat-in kitchen with white cabinetry, newer countertop and luxury vinyl flooring (2024). Stainless appliances include fridge (2025), range, dishwasher, & microwave. When you desire extra living space, you'll find it, in the home's formal dining & living rooms. The first floor half bath offers convenience. Upstairs, you'll enjoy the spaciousness of the primary bedroom, along with two nicely sized secondary bedrooms, and a very nice full bathroom! The unfinished basement offers a fully equipped laundry (Washer, dryer, & laundry tub) and lots of extra space to add a rec room, exercise room, etc. AustintownSchools but Weathersfield Schools offer open enrollment. Buyer must verify that Weathersfield enrollment is still open. Updates: hot water tank (2026); pool pump head valve & pool heater display (2025); deck rebuilt(2024); luxury vinyl flooring, in kitchen, family room, & bathrooms (2024); pool pump (2022); HVAC (2018); and roof with 50 year shingles (2011). Watcha waitin' for? It's time to live!

Listing Courtesy of

YES MLS / Listed By: Kimberly "Kim" Sauerwein, Century 21 Lakeside Realty

$279,000 ^(USD)

Hitchcock Woods Area Single Family Home

547 Squirrel Hill Drive Youngstown, OH 44512

Meticulously maintained home. This one checks all the boxes, four bedrooms, master suite with full bath, fenced in yard, fireplace, finished basement and so much more. Located in Boardman schools, this home has good bones. You can feel the love and care the minute you walk in the front door. Guest can be entertained in either the large formal living room or relax in the cozy family room while snuggled up to the fireplace. Summertime ready with a full view sunroom, paved patio, hot tub and private back yard for the family to enjoy. The curved staircase leads you to the upstairs where all four bedroom are located with two full baths. The lower level features a partially finished basement for extra enjoyment.

Listing Courtesy of

YES MLS / Listed By: Dawn Nicholas, Century 21 Lakeside Realty

$277,400 ^(USD)

Elmknoll Heights Area Single Family Home

3151 Heatherbrae Drive Poland, OH 44514

This gorgeous two-story home is set on a quiet street in a desirable Poland neighborhood and offers the perfect blend of timeless character and modern updates. With 1,720 square feet of living space, three bedrooms, one and a half baths, and multiple gathering areas, this property is designed for both everyday comfort and entertaining.

Curb appeal stands out with newer vinyl siding accented by Craftsman-style details, brand-new exterior and garage doors, a newer roof, and a cozy front porch for relaxing outdoors.

Inside, hardwood floors run through much of the home, including all three upstairs bedrooms, each with generous closet space and abundant natural light. The main bath has been tastefully updated, while a convenient half bath serves the first floor.

The eat-in kitchen features newer luxury vinyl floors, ample counter space, and updated appliances that stay. It opens directly into the family room, anchored by a striking stone fireplace. A spacious living room and formal dining room, both with hardwood floors, provide additional options for hosting.

An inviting all-season room overlooks the backyard and adds versatile living space to enjoy year-round. The large lot includes a patio and shed, offering room to spread out and entertain.

Additional highlights include a full basement with laundry and storage space, central air, and a spacious attached two-car garage with opener. This meticulously maintained home combines charm, tons of updates, and a wonderful location! Schedule your showing today!

Listing Courtesy of

YES MLS / Listed By: Zakk "Zachary" Easterbrook, Century 21 Lakeside Realty

$276,000 ^(USD)

Poland Village Area Single Family Home

112 N Lima Road Poland, OH 44514

There’s nothing like the feeling of walking into a warm and cozy home as the snow files outside in the cold Ohio winters! When that home is lovingly kept, tastefully updated and beautifully presented; you might not want to come back outside until spring. Welcome to this darling Poland residence, waiting for you to take off your jacket and pick up a warm cup of cocoa as you count snowflakes from the tableside. Sat deep into the lot just seconds from downtown; this engaging estate has a lot to be excited for. A covered front porch adds to the curb appeal while a sweeping driveway finds a detached two car garage and casual, rear entryway. Through the front door, a vestibule style foyer includes a coat closet as you peer through the glass into the inviting living room. Here, a crackling fireplace is surrounded by tall windows while hardwood flooring runs underfoot. Thick trimwork and rustic appeal present themselves throughout the home to include the nearby formal dining room with its decorative lighting. Opposite the living room, a gracious family room presents its wrapping casement shelves while a charming half bath hides away near the staircase. Completing the floor, a must-see kitchen includes a farmhouse styled basin sink and polished stone countertops that include a coffee bar near eat-in dining. Upstairs, four impressively sized bedrooms line the hall as they join an expansive full bath with a corner spa and private stall shower. Heavy use of large ceramic tiles adds to the appeal. The larger master bedroom rounds things out with its row of windows that overlook the front yard. Laundry and storage are located at the basement level. From cozy winter nights to warm summer evenings on the porch, this Poland classic is ready for its next chapter. If you can picture yourself here, don’t wait—reach out today to schedule your private showing before someone else beats you to the cocoa.

Listing Courtesy of

YES MLS / Listed By: Brokers Realty Group

$276,000 ^(USD)

Charles W Smith Area Single Family Home

7085 Youngstown Pittsburgh Road Poland, OH 44514

Unbelievable Opportunity in Historic Poland, Ohio! Welcome to this stunning 4–5 bedroom home, perfectly located in the heart of Poland Village. This beautifully updated property combines classic charm with modern amenities throughout & road access from 224 & Poland Village Blvd. The first floor boasts an expansive, fully renovated kitchen featuring brand-new cabinetry, sleek countertops, and stainless steel appliances — truly a chef’s dream. Enjoy entertaining in the spacious formal dining room and elegant living room, plus the convenience of a stylish half bath. Upstairs, you’ll find a generous master suite complete with a fully updated private bath. Two additional bedrooms and a second renovated full bath provide comfort and flexibility for family or guests. The third floor is fully finished, offering a large fourth bedroom and a versatile office or bonus space. The finished lower level expands your living space with a large family room and dedicated laundry area plus steps for outdoor access. Outside, you’ll love the new front steps, a fresh concrete pad in the back, and a detached two-car garage. The big new paved back parking lot & driveway runs from Route 224 to Poland Village Blvd, offering extra parking for guests, campers, trailers, or recreational vehicles. This driveway gives you access on 224 & Poland Village Blvd. offering extreme convenience. Additional updates include: • New hot water tank (2025) • New roof (2020) • Mostly new windows, all new doors, and all new flooring • Fresh interior paint throughout *New Expanded Concrete Back & Side Drive Don’t miss this rare find with room to grow, entertain, and enjoy — all in one of Poland’s most desirable neighborhoods!

Listing Courtesy of

YES MLS / Listed By: Keller Williams Chervenic Rlty

$275,000 ^(USD)

Shepherds Hill Area Single Family Home

289 Cricklewood Drive Cortland, OH 44410

Located in The Shepherds Hill Allotment Development, Beautiful 4 Bed, 3 Bath Home in a quiet, desirable neighborhood, this well-maintained home offers comfort, functionality, and timeless appeal. Featuring a thoughtful layout with spacious living areas, this property is ideal for homeowners seeking both relaxation and everyday convenience.
The inviting living room flows seamlessly into the dining area and kitchen, creating a perfect space for entertaining or family gatherings. Generous natural light enhances the home's warm and welcoming atmosphere. Boasting a first floor primary suite, all bedrooms are comfortably sized, offering privacy to family, guests, or alternate use as a home office.
Outside, enjoy a peaceful yard ideal for outdoor entertaining, gardening, or simply unwinding after a long day. The property also offers ample parking and storage, adding to its practicality.
Conveniently located near schools, shopping, dining, and major routes, this home combines suburban tranquility with easy access to everything Cortland has to offer.
Located in the highly regarded Lakeview Local School District, widely considered one of the top school districts in Trumbull County. Known for strong academic performance, community support, and long-term property value appeal.

Listing Courtesy of

YES MLS / Listed By: Nicholas Phillips, Century 21 Lakeside Realty

Home

Properties

About Me

Blog

Neighborhood News

Terms Of Use | Privacy Policy | Accessibility Statement | Fair Housing Notice

© 2026 MoxiWorks

© CENTURY 21 2023 - 2024. All rights reserved. CENTURY 21®, C21® and the CENTURY 21 Logo are registered service marks owned by Century 21 Real Estate LLC. Franchisee Legal Entity Name (not the dba) fully supports the principles of the Fair Housing Act and the Equal Opportunity Act. Each franchise is independently owned and operated. Any services or products provided by independently owned and operated franchisees are not provided by, affiliated with, or related to Century 21 Real Estate LLC nor any of its affiliated companies.